Market segmentation and mobile phones

PAYG handsets brought mobile phones to the mass market.  The next challenge for the mobile phone industry was to get people to buy more phones, upgrade their old phone and own more than one.

Most adopted some for of segmentation strategy in the late 90s and early 2000s.  Segmentation means dividing the market into segments and making a different product for each segment. All of the big three mobile phone makers: Ericsson, Motorola and Nokia developed separate business and consumer phones, but segmentation became far more complex towards the end of the 90s.

From 1999, Motorola developed four distinct segments: Accompli, Timeport, V and Talkabout. Accompli was aimed at users wanting the latest technology; Timeport was for business users; V phones for fashion conscious users and Talkabout were mass market consumer phones.[1].

Nokia became a master of segmentation and took the strategy to extreme and excess from 2005 onwards.

Nokia's segmentation strategy

As early as 1998 Nokia had recognised that segmentation was key to continued market leadership. They also recognised that users would upgrade frequently to take advantage of changes in technology. Their policy was to develop a flow of new models and to cater for every sector of the market.[2]

Nokia's segmentation approach eventually covered all sectors of the market from first time users, to business users, fashion conscious young professionals, top executives and sports men and women needing a rugged phone that would take hard knocks.

Nokia developed separate business and consumer phones from the early 90s, and developed a handset for the premium market, the 8110, in 1996.  The 8110 was a premium phone because its design, size and shape set it apart from other Nokia phone and the competition.  However, what followed was something entirely different.

The Premium Segment

In 1998, Nokia's Chief Designer Frank Nuovo styled a new phone, the 8810.  It was designed to be the mobile phone equivalent of a premium watch or fountain pen. It had advanced features, including an infra red port, Nokia's famous menu system and an impressive 133 hours of standby time on the standard battery, but the point of the 8810 was desirability from its look and feel and from the materials used in its manufacture. The sliding chrome look case was nice to hold and the phone was easy to use. It was one of the most desirable Christmas presents of 1998.

The 8810 was the first Nokia phone specifically aimed at the 'Premium' segment. Nokia released several new phones in the premium class each more luxurious than its predecessor. The 8850 was aluminium, the 8890, titanium.

The appeal of these phones in rapidly growing Asian markets was not lost.  There was a gold version of 8850 designed specially for the Hong Kong market.   Nokia may have had an eye to these markets with the choice of the 88 prefix in the model number.

The final incarnation of this line was the steel bodied slider phone, the  Nokia 8800.  It took the analogy other luxury products to extremes. Journalists from East and West drooled over the precision craftsmanship, more familiar to luxury watchmakers,  reinforced scratch resistant glass and ball bearings used in the sports car industry.

Nokia premium phones

The Fashion segment

Nokia designers recognised that there was an important group of consumers who wanted something more than the most basic mobile phone. Whilst the premium range of phones mainly targeted top executives, younger style conscious buyers were looking for something else.

Nokia started this concept with the 5110, in 1998. It was Nokia's first phone with interchangeable fascias. The company worked hard to promote the phone's fashion credentials. However, 5110 was in reality little more than a basic consumer phone. It was the first in a series of basic phones which included the 3210 and the ubiquitous 3310.

A year later Nokia launched the 8210, which was Nokia's smallest and lightest phone to date. It was clearly a cut above more basic phones such as the 5110 and it's replacements.

Nokia designers continued to work hard in this segment producing a range of phones which offered stylish cases and innovative new features. The 8310 had different interchangeable covers, the front, the back and the middle and an FM radio. The 7210 had a colour screen and a new stylish case. The 7250 added a camera.

Nokia's model numbers were a little bit confusing. The first fashion phones were 8000 series phones: the 8210 and 8310. However, after that fashion phones used 7000 series numbers: 7210, 7250 and the 7260, 7270 and 7280. The latter being the famous 'lipstick' phone, clearly targeting the female consumer.

Nokia fashion phones

The Classic segment

Nokia's mainstream business phones became the Classic segment. The first true classic phone was the Nokia 6110 which was developed alongside the 5110 fashion phone.  It did not offer interchangeable fascias, but was more targeted at business users with an infra red port and slimline battery. 

The 6110 was the first of a line of phones which included Nokia's 6310i, one of the most loved Nokia's every.  The 6310i offered tri-band GSM, it was the first Nokia to do so.  It earned a reputation for ease of use and for durability that meant it was favoured by businesses users long after it went out of production.

Nokia's Classic phones

The Entry Segment

Nokia from the very beginning sort to bring mobiles to people. Whilst they captured the headlines of the technology press with some of the coolest phones and all time and provided business users with solid reliable work tools, they also catered to the mass market supplying some of the most popular phones of all time.

Nokia's early entry level phones included the Nokia 1610, which gave exceptional battery life and the cheap and cheerful analogue Nokia Ringo which became one of the UK's first PAYG handsets.

However, Nokia did not enter the race for the cheapest phone in the early days of PAYG. Most of their consumer phones were aimed first at contract customers.

Nokia's 5110 bridged the fashion and Entry segments. Once smaller and slicker phones were available the 5110 became entry level. The phones that followed it, the 3210 and 3310, both offered interchangeable fascias. Both marketed intially initially as contract only phones they later became available on PAYG.

The 3310 became a massive selling phone. It seemed at one time that almost everyone had one of these. Nokia did it again with the Nokia 1100 which became the World's best selling phone.

Nokia basic/entry level phones

Other segments

Expression

Nokia decided that there was a segment that sat between 'Fashion' and 'Basic/Entry'. Fashion phones were aimed at the top of the consumer market and basic was about your first phone. So to fully exploit this market Nokia launched the 'Expression' segment.

Expression phones offered customisation in terms of a huge range of fascia and keyboard options, but lagged behind the fashion phones in terms of features.

Nokia Expression phones included:

Nokia's market segmentation approach identified seven different segments:[3]

Premium

Nokia first ventured into the premium category in 1996, adding the Nokia 8110 to top their existing GSM range. The 8110 brought classic Scandinavian design aesthetics to a phone that was smaller, lighter and more stylish than Nokia's ground breaking business phone the 2110.

Nokia's Chief Designer Frank Nuovo styled the 8810 to become the embodiment of the premium class phone. Nuovo created the mobile phone equivalent of a premium watch or fountain pen. Yes, it had advanced features, including an infra red port, Nokia's famous menu system and an impressive 133 hours of standby time on the standard battery, but the point of the 8810 was desirability. The sliding chrome look case was nice to hold and the phone was easy to use. It was one the most desirable Christmas presents of 1998.

Nokia continued the premium line with the 8850, which replaced chrome look plastic with aluminium and the 8910 which had a similar look with a titanium case. The appeal of these phones in rapidly growing Asian markets was not lost.  There was a gold version of 8850 designed specially for the Hong Kong market.   Nokia may have had an eye to these markets with the choice of the 88 prefix in the model number.

The final incarnation of this line was the steel bodied slider phone, the  Nokia 8800.  It took the analogy other luxury products to extremes. Journalists from East and West drooled over the precision craftsmanship, more familiar to luxury watchmakers,  reinforced scratch resistant glass and ball bearings used in the sports car industry.

The premium sector was profitable for Nokia for a time, however, ultimately technology drove the utility of mobile phones and it is difficult to see the 8800 series along side timeless classics like Rolex watches or Mont Blanc pens.

Nokia premium phones

Fashion

Nokia designers recognised that there was an important group of consumers who wanted something more than the most basic mobile phone. Whilst the premium range of phones mainly targeted top executives, younger style conscious buyers were looking for something else.

Nokia started this concept with the 5110, in 1998. It was Nokia's first phone with interchangeable fascias. The company worked hard to promote the phone's fashion credentials. However, 5110 was in reality little more than a basic consumer phone. It was the first in a series of basic phones which included the 3210 and the ubiquitous 3310.

A year later Nokia launched the 8210, which was Nokia's smallest and lightest phone to date. It was clearly a cut above more basic phones such as the 5110 and it's replacements.

Nokia designers continued to work hard in this segment producing a range of phones which offered stylish cases and innovative new features. The 8310 had different interchangeable covers, the front, the back and the middle and an FM radio. The 7210 had a colour screen and a new stylish case. The 7250 added a camera.

Nokia's model numbers were a little bit confusing. The first fashion phones were 8000 series phones: the 8210 and 8310. However, after that fashion phones used 7000 series numbers: 7210, 7250 and the 7260, 7270 and 7280. The latter being the famous 'lipstick' phone, clearly targeting the female consumer.

Nokia fashion phones

Classic

Initially mobile phones were aimed at business users. So the the origing

Nokia classic series

Expression

Basic/Entry

Active

In the early days of mobile phones, owning a mobile phone was ruinously expensive and manufacturers targeted only business users. However, once prices dropped enough for consumers to consider mobile phones, there were phones aimed specifically at this market. One2One had consumers in mind with its M200 and M300 phones and a tariff offering free off peak calls. However, aside from offering cheap and cheerful phones, or last years model at the bottom end of the range there was little targeting of individual groups.

Nokia was one of the first companies to realise that as the market expanded different groups would need different products.

As mobile phones became more popular it was clear that different consumer groups had different d

Usability was key to Nokia's success in the early 90s. In the second part of the 90s it was market segmentation which ensured the firm's continued dominance of the mobile phone industry.

References

1. An Analysis on the Conditions and Methods of Market Segmentation, Shili Sun, School of Foreign Languages, Ludong University; published in the International Journal of Business and Management, February 2009

2. Nokia report and account, 1998

3. New thinking, new potential; presentation by Juha Pinomaa, Director, Product Marketing, Nokia (2003)

Article by Steven Braggs, June 2012

 
   
Mobile phone history